Harry Potter Plagiarism Again?

J. K. Rowling has once again been slapped with a plagiarism lawsuit.  I fully expect that it will be summarily dismissed based on a comment on this description of the legal action.  "The plagiarism allegation concerned the story plot rather than the words."  But what is copyrighted in every case is the words, their placement and usage, their accumulation into a work.  You cannot copyright an idea, not even an idea like an entire plot.  If not, then we would lose a substantial part of the world of the Romance Novelists--there are limited permutations and combinations of events and incidents.  Plots--a wizard challenge (for example) are the structural backbone of writing, but I'm willing to bet if one went to the Index of Folklore and mythology, such a challenge of witches and wizards would be a fairly common theme. 

Comments

  1. FredFebruary 18, 2010 at 7:54 PM

    I agree. General plot themes can't be copyrighted. Otherwise, no stories could be written today.

    For example, Ursula Le Guin's "Earthsea Trilogy" begins with a young boy who has magic powers and is sent to a wizard's school to learn how to develop, use, and control them.

    ReplyDelete
  2. StevenFebruary 19, 2010 at 7:50 AM

    Dear Fred,

    Gosh, I guess Ms. Rowling stole from Ms. Le Guin too, huh? If we prosecuted every case of such "theft" we'd have no literature left. Add that to draconian and idiotic copyright laws and let's see how fast we can take down the thriving world of literature. Shakespeare--sorry can't be performed, he stole from Pyramus and Thisbe. Oh, and we can forget West Side Story. _Ran_ get that right out of here we need only one Lear. And so forth--you get my drift, as shown in the comment. Thanks.

    shalom,

    Steven

    ReplyDelete
  3. FredFebruary 19, 2010 at 10:24 AM

    Steven,

    And I wouldn't be surprised if someone had published a story about a school for wizards before Le Guin wrote her series.

    Along with _Ran_, one could add _Throne of Blood_ and to reciprocate, _The Magnificent Seven_ too, or _Star Wars_.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Robert de Boron and the Prose Merlin

There are so many wonderful things about the internet: there was a time when a scholar had to order through ILL and wait for weeks or months before he or she could set eyes on such works as Geoffrey of Monmouth's Vita Merlini or Robert de Boron's Prose Merlin . No more. from Prose Merlin Robert de Boron Full wrothe and angry was the Devell, whan that oure Lorde hadde ben in helle and had take oute Adam and Eve and other at his plesier. And whan the fendes sien that, they hadden right grete feer and gret merveile. Thei assembleden togedir and seiden: "What is he this thus us supprisith and distroyeth, in so moche that oure strengthes ne nought ellis that we have may nought withholde hym, nor again hym stonde in no diffence but that he doth all that hym lyketh? We ne trowed not that eny man myght be bore of woman but that he sholde ben oures; and he that thus us distroyeth, how is he born in whom we knewe non erthely delyte?" Than ansuerde anothir fende and seide
Read more

Another Queen of Night

I post this because whenever I recommend to anyone the Queen of Night, I always recommend it in the Lucia Popp rendition.  It's a matter of personal taste, but what I love about this is that it is somewhat slower than the other versions and as a result, it would seem to me somewhat more difficult to perform and sustain--those high notes in which the Queen's voice becomes the Magic Flute itself are rounded, full, and deep while remaining light and airy. I have read some rather severe criticism of this ritardando; and while it may or may not reflect Mozart's intent, it is certainly within the options for staging.  It creates a real vocal showpiece from what is already a magnificent example of same. It really is an amazing example of a virtuoso composition sung by a virtuoso voice.  All of which should not be taken to mean that I do not truly appreciate the version posted earlier by Diana Damrau, it's just nice to see what a difference tempo can make. I think we can take
Read more